Five questions to ask before recruiting your charity's next CEO

Jenny Hills • November 17, 2026

Recruiting the right CEO for your charity requires a clear understanding of the role, but it’s often so reflective of the current incumbent that it’s difficult to envisage it without them.


Fortunately, Jenny Hills of Harris Hill Executive Search has five key questions that will help you and fellow stakeholders to define the role, determine what's important and understand what to look for, setting you up for a successful search...


Palm tree against a clear turquoise sky


Five questions to ask before recruiting your charity's next CEO


If you're about to recruit a new Chief Executive, defining the brief can feel daunting. Most trustees and Chairs don't recruit CEOs very often, if ever, so it can be difficult to know where to start.


The questions below are ones we regularly ask clients during the briefing stage of executive search assignments. They are big questions, but as you will see, they give a more practical starting point to defining a brief rather than diving straight in to writing a job description and person specification, or trying to update such documents if they have not been reviewed in a long time. They also help organisations think beyond simply replacing the outgoing postholder and instead define what the role really needs to achieve.


While these questions are particularly valuable when recruiting a CEO, they're equally applicable to other senior strategic appointments that will have a significant impact across an organisation.


Assuming your organisation can already clearly describe its mission, values, strategy, governance, funding model and other core information, the questions below are designed to get to the heart of what your workplace is like, what the CEO role really involves, what success looks like, and what kind of leader will be best placed to deliver it.


Gray banner with a small “CEO” label on the left and pink question marks on the right

Q1: What surprises people when they first join your organisation?


Who to ask: All key stakeholders, but particularly newer members of staff.


Why it's helpful: Your new CEO is going to be joining your organisation soon. Surprises – particularly unpleasant ones – can affect whether someone settles successfully into a role, so it's far better to be open about the realities of the organisation during the recruitment process.


On the other hand, positive surprises often make some of your strongest selling points - we have often found that information given in response to this question is invaluable when we are engaging with candidates who really want to get to know an organisation.


One charity with under 40 staff turned out to have an incredibly strong social aspect to its culture, with active clubs for baking, books, running and more - none of which appeared on their website, annual report, job descriptions, or anywhere else, but this helped paint a clear picture of what it was like to work there and the culture.


The question often identifies things that may not be immediately obvious to longer-serving staff or trustees because they've become part of everyday life, but they can be exactly the things that attract the right candidates.



Section divider consisting of a light grey horizontal line with blue 'HH' icon at the centre.

Q2: If the current CEO went off to sit on a beach and never returned, what would go wrong or stop happening, and how quickly? What would continue just fine for the foreseeable future?


Who to ask: Staff and trustees.


Why it's helpful: The answers to this thought-experiment question reveal what the role really is and, therefore, the priority skills, experience and knowledge required. If something major would break down quickly without somebody covering it, you know that's a key responsibility for the new postholder.


Equally, this exercise can reveal structural weaknesses. Sometimes responsibilities that sit outside the intended scope of the role turn out to be entirely dependent on the CEO simply because that's how things have evolved over time. Identifying these dependencies gives you the opportunity to rethink how responsibilities are allocated before automatically building them into the next job description and person specification (which could risk ruling out or putting off perfectly good candidates).


Hand holding a microphone beside question-mark speech bubbles on a gray background


Q3: What three things do you wish you'd been told when you joined?


Who to ask: The outgoing CEO.


Alternative question: If the CEO has been in post for many years, or the organisation has changed significantly during their tenure, ask: "What three things do you want your successor to know about this role?"


Why it's helpful: Every CEO accumulates knowledge that never quite makes it into a handover note or job description. They know which relationships take time to build, where the real decision-making happens, what challenges are likely to arise, and what they wish they'd understood sooner.


Asking this question helps capture that tacit knowledge before it's lost. It can also highlight aspects of the role that should be reflected in the brief or explored during interviews. Sometimes the answers reinforce the importance of certain skills or experience; sometimes they reveal misconceptions candidates commonly have about the role or organisation. Either way, it gives the recruitment panel a richer understanding of what the next CEO needs to know in order to succeed.


Other useful questions to ask your outgoing CEO include “What are the challenges, opportunities, projects, etc, that are going to be immediately on your successor’s plate?” and “What would your immediate priorities be if you were to step into this role afresh?”.


No one knows this role – at least how it has been performed up until this point – better than your current CEO, so listen carefully to their insight even if the board would like to explore a different profile or strategic directions.



Blue CEO cap on the left, with question mark icons on the right


Q4: How would you know you'd made the right appointment in one year's time? What would success look like?



Who to ask: All key stakeholders.


Why it's helpful: This question helps establish what the organisation expects the new CEO to achieve in the short term.


Just as importantly, it helps test whether everyone is aligned on those expectations. If some stakeholders are focused on stabilisation while others are expecting rapid growth or transformation, it's much better to surface and reconcile those differences before the recruitment process begins.


Once you've agreed what success looks like, it's much easier to work backwards and identify the experience, leadership style and capabilities that should be prioritised in the person specification.


Section divider consisting of a light grey horizontal line with blue 'HH' icon at the centre.


Q5: What would success look like in five years' time?


Who to ask: All key stakeholders, but particularly board members.


Why it's helpful: This question encourages the board to think beyond immediate priorities and consider the longer-term direction of the organisation.


The answers can be invaluable when shaping the brief. For example, if one of your ambitions is to increase your charity's national policy influence, you'll know to prioritise candidates with the strategic leadership, external profile and influencing experience needed to deliver that ambition.


Clearly articulating what success looks like also helps candidates assess whether they're the right fit. It enables them to compare their own experience, strengths and aspirations with what the board is looking to achieve. If their vision of success is significantly different from the organisation's, it's better for everyone to recognise that early in the process.


Finally, sharing these success measures helps bring the opportunity to life. Most people choose to work in the charity sector because they want to make a meaningful difference. Being clear about the impact the successful candidate will be expected to have makes that opportunity much more tangible and compelling.



Purple question marks and a cloud of words like strategy, experience, success, opportunity etc

Who should be involved?


We have made some suggestions of who to discuss these topics with, but that is by no means a limitation. While it is ultimately the board's responsibility (or that of a delegated committee of trustees) to define the role and make the appointment, the best briefs are rarely developed in isolation. 


The senior leadership team will often provide invaluable insight into what the organisation needs from its next CEO, and it would be strange not to seek input from the outgoing CEO unless there are compelling reasons not to, but there is also real value in hearing from a broader cross-section of staff and volunteers who work alongside the Chief Executive day to day. 


Many charities also benefit from seeking the views of service users, particularly when discussing what success in the role would look like, and some choose to involve key funders or strategic partners for an external perspective. Gathering these different viewpoints can significantly strengthen the brief, provided there is clarity throughout the process about where decision-making ultimately sits and who is responsible for agreeing the final brief.


The quality of your brief shapes the quality of your appointment.


The best recruitment briefs don't just describe a role – they paint a picture of the difference you want your next leader to make.


Taking the time to explore questions like these helps build a shared understanding amongst trustees, senior colleagues and key stakeholders, identifies the qualities and experience that really matter, and gives candidates a much clearer sense of the opportunity, the challenges and the impact they could have.


At Harris Hill Executive Search, facilitating these conversations at the briefing stage is the foundation of every appointment we take on. A thoughtful, well-defined brief doesn't just make for a smoother recruitment process; it helps attract leaders who connect with your charity's purpose, share your values, and have the skills and experience to lead your organisation into its next chapter.


Jenny Hills, Director

Harris Hill Executive Search


Harris Hill Executive Search banner with gray background, blue question marks, and white logo text.


If you'd like more information or any assistance with a potential brief, please contact our Executive Search team via the details below, call 020 7820 7300, or email executive@harrishill.co.uk


Nick Shanks, Director

07766 538575

Email Nick


Jenny Hills, Director

020 7820 7321

Email Jenny


Aled Morris, CEO

020 7820 7301

Email Aled



You can also find more about the team, how we work and many of our previous appointments in our new Executive Search hub here, or by clicking below.


Robot teacher at a board reading “How to write your supporting statement in the age of AI.”
By David Young • November 2, 2026
Thanks to the magic of AI, it’s never been easier to write a supporting statement. But because magic is fickle and probably not real, it’s never been harder to outshine all the other AI-assisted applicants. So how do you write a standout statement with (or without) your chatbot of choice?
Harris Hill salary survey 2026 graphic for temporary, fixed-term, contract and interim jobs in purple icons
By David Young • October 26, 2026
While permanent roles are increasingly struggling to live up to that label, how are things looking for the kind of jobs that wear their short-lived status on their sleeve? Here’s what our temporary and interim specialists had to say about the market in the 2026 Harris Hill Salary Survey.