Image 2023 08 08 T03 44 42

How to secure new talent (without spending a fortune)

Search by
Search by blog tags

Candidate scarcity and high inflation have made securing new staff more challenging (and expensive) than ever, but there ARE ways to improve your hiring prospects that needn't cost a thing...

Beyond the world of marketing, where they grow on carefully-branded trees, our latest Salary Survey finds candidates in short supply and high demand throughout the sector.

It’s the classic recipe for rising wages, but with charity sector pockets only so deep, what happens if there's no more money to throw at the problem? How can you attract the new staff you need to move forward?

Well, the good news is that while the general outlook might still seem bleaker than a week in Walford, there are (at least) three key steps you can take to maximise your chances of a successful hire, at no extra cost.


1. Be specific about the salary

‘Say what it is’ might seem to come straight from the insultingly-obvious school of advice, but being upfront and transparent really does make a difference.

Keen to maximise applications, many employers like to leave salaries open to interpretation, and if you happen to interpret more than is actually available, well, that’s on you. And often intentional.

Take a job advertised at £38-44k. In the minds of many candidates, that’s a £42k job at least, because with their skills and experience, of course they’ll be offered something towards the upper end. To the employer, it’s a £38k job they might just have to pay a little more for, in exceptional cases.

Meanwhile, the top end of £44k may be less a potential salary than simply a bid to attract high-calibre candidates at that level, hoping they’ll miraculously accept a lower rate once they get to know the organisation.

However [SPOILER ALERT]: they won’t. Not even for you. Which likely means repeating the process, with all the time, resources and cost that implies.

Ultimately, there’s no point attracting talent with salaries you’re not going to pay. Don’t say ‘circa £70k’ if the maximum offer will be £65k, or ‘£36-42k’ if Mother Teresa herself wouldn’t get more than £37k.

Overstating, exaggerating or giving a misleading impression of the salary might initially attract more eyeballs, but the real figure will have to be disclosed at some stage. If it's lower than candidates were led to believe, their trust will evaporate and the time (which, as we all know, is money) will be wasted, since someone who feels lured into applying under false pretences is never going to take the job.

Even if it's not particularly impressive, stating a specific salary has several advantages:
  • It becomes a known quantity, which can often win the day against an offer that claims to be higher, but has yet to be confirmed.

  • It says several good things about the organisation: that you're open and honest, that you respect and value applicants enough not to waste their time, that what you say can be trusted, and that the same salary applies regardless of who gets the job, suggesting a fair and equitable approach overall.

  • Those who apply will be doing so with their eyes open, fully aware of the pay, and having done their sums to make sure it's viable for them. As such, when you come to make an offer, there's a very good chance they'll accept, filling the vacancy at the first attempt. It's far more efficient and cost-effective than taking someone all the way through the interview process, only to lose them with a lower-than-expected offer and having to start again.

2. Be fast

If you can’t outbid the competition, outrun them: being quick off the mark is a real asset in this fast-moving market.

The key is to ensure candidates are never waiting too long without news. Acknowledge applications as they arrive and if interviews are some way off, an initial screening call can at least engage them in the process early on.

Online interviews save a lot of time, and in our experience, often yield better results as candidates are more relaxed in their own environment.

Either way, make swift decisions and share them promptly: at least half of today’s workforce have grown up in an on-demand, instant-feedback world where more than a week feels an impossibly archaic time to wait for anything.

Again, remember time is money: if protracted negotiations result in saving £3k on the salary, but the vacancy goes unfilled for another two months as a result, is it really a saving?

3. Be flexible

Flexibility: essential in a beanbag, and just as popular in the workplace, with flexible working being a major draw for the majority of candidates.

In the last few years, flexibility has grown from a fairly niche concern to challenging salary as candidates' number one requirement. So even if raising the salary isn't an option, offering greater flexibility may be just as effective.

And with studies and experience consistently showing there’s little downside to doing so, becoming applicants’ most flexible choice could be a smart way to make you their first. ​

Of course, in a cost-of-living crisis, there's no denying that the highest offer on the table will often win the day.

However, by making the salary a known quantity, moving fast and out-flexing the rest – probably not a word but go with it, we’re nearly there – you provide multiple grounds for candidates to consider your opportunity the better offer.


For more on salaries, hiring trends and current rates for more than 200 charity sector positions, check out the Harris Hill Salary Survey here, contact our specialist consultants, or give us a call on 020 7820 7300.

Search jobs

Recruit for your organisation

Read the Harris Hill Blog

  • Image 2022 11 26 T23 39 23

    Opportunity for all

    Find out how we’re working to deliver more diverse, equitable and inclusive recruitment…

    Find out more

  • Image 2022 11 26 T23 39 23

    Recruiting a charity CEO?

    Our executive recruitment specialists have an exceptional record of successful CEO, chair, trustee and…

    Find out more

  • The Harris Hill Salary Survey 2024

    Charity sector salaries

    Our 2025 Salary Survey has the latest rates and expert insight for roles throughout the sector.

    Find out more

News and insights

For more careers and recruitment advice: Read the Harris Hill Blog
Blogthumb Temps Min

2025 Salary Survey: temps market trends

​Tough economic times have certainly had an impact on the number of permanent hires that charities have been able to make this year, but what about temporary and interim positions?Here's what our Temps specialists had to say about the trends they're seeing in the market, in our 2025 Salary Survey.​​It says everything about the current market that this is the only one of our specialist areas to ...

Read more
Blogthumb Finance

2025 Salary Survey: finance market trends

Say you work in finance and many will imagine a world of six-figure salaries, baffling spreadsheets, detached houses in the Home Counties and a statistically inexplicable number of people called Steve. Working in charity finance however, is – baffling spreadsheets aside – a rather different story, but with their finger on the pulse and their ear to the ground at all times (we should really get ...

Read more
Business Services Blogthumb Min

2025 Salary Survey: business services market trends

The roles we group under ‘Business Services’ aren’t about raising funds or raising profile, but about delivering an organisation’s work – including operational staff at all levels, project managers, programme leaders and all the admin, data and support staff in less visible roles that are nonetheless essential to getting things done. So what’s happening in the recruitment market for those work...

Read more
Blogthumb3 Min

Charity salaries: the ten-year trends

How have charity salaries progressed in the last 10 years? Who's seen the highest and lowest increases? And how has the sector fared against others and the cost of living? Our 2025 Salary Survey gives us a tenth year of directly comparable data, so this time, along with the latest rates for third sector jobs, we look at the longer-term changes too, travelling back to 2015 to compare rates of pa...

Read more
Blogthumb Marketing

2025 Salary Survey: marketing, PR and digital trends

As a charity professional, your experience of working and job-seeking in the sector will very much depend on the type of work you do, which is why our 2025 Salary Survey looks at the trends and challenges for each specialist area in turn. You can find the figures for all departments in the full survey here, but in the meantime, here’s what we’re currently seeing in the market for those in marke...

Read more
Blogthumb Fundraising

2025 Salary Survey: fundraising market trends

Driven by high demand and short supply, fundraisers' salaries have been rising in recent years, but how have things changed in the last 12 months? What kind of roles are organisations offering and which are the most challenging to fill? Here's what our fundraising specialists had to say in our 2025 Salary Survey (available here).​​It’s not the way we might want it to happen, but a combination o...

Read more
Blogthumb1

2025 Salary Survey: market overview

​The 2025 Harris Hill Salary Survey is out now (get your copy here), reporting on charity and not-for-profit sector salaries over the last 12 months, with the latest rates and expert insight for each of our specialist areas. This year we're also looking at how pay in the sector has evolved over the last 10 years, but first, here's what we had to say about the charity recruitment market in 2025....

Read more
Blogthumb1a

Has remote working replaced human connection?

​The way we communicate at work has changed dramatically over the past few years. With an array of digital tools and social platforms at our fingertips, we're communicating and meeting more frequently and efficiently than ever. But is digital evolution at the cost of meaningful connection?If we rely too much on Teams and not enough on being a team, what do we leave behind? Freelance writer Nico...

Read more